“There are people who fast and get nothing from their fast except hunger, and there are those who pray and get nothing from their prayer but a sleepless night.” How should we understand this hadith?
Submitted by on Mon, 18/02/2019 - 14:41
Dear Brother / Sister,
The hadith above was reported by Ibn Majah (Siyam, 21). Its meaning is as follows: If a person cannot avoid committing sins, which is the real purpose of fasting, when he fasts, it means he does not benefit from fasting as it is necessary. It does not mean such fasting is of no use.
Another narration regarding the issue is as follows:
“Whoever does not give up evil and ignorant speech, and acting in accordance with that, Allah has no need of his giving up his food and drink.” (ibid)
What is meant by ignorance is not to know about Allah’s orders and prohibitions and high ethics as it is necessary and hence to do bad deeds that Islam does not accept.
If a person who fasts protects his stomach from halal (legitimate) things but does not protect his tongue, eyes, ears, hands, feet, heart and mind, even his imagination, from haram (illegitimate) things, it means he has not fulfilled fasting properly.
This hadith shows how important the consciousness of worshipping and belief is. From this point of view, a Muslim should try to worship with his body and spirit.
The hadith above and similar ones do not want people to abandon worship but to fulfil deeds of worship more carefully and more consciously.
Questions on Islam
- Will you give information about the source and interpretation of the hadith "Cleanliness is from belief"?
- How should the expression "is not (one) of us" mentioned in some hadiths be understood? For instance, "He who cheats us is not one of us." "He who sleeps on a full stomach while his neighbor is hungry is not one of us."
- How is the state of those who hold fast to the religion at the end of time described in hadiths?
- Are there any verses supporting directly the hadith "But for you, I would not have created the universe"?
- How should the hadith "to want for his believing brother what one wants for himself" be understood?
- Will you explain the hadith, "The best ones among you are the ones who make people remember Allah when they are seen"?
- Are there any hadiths related to apologizing?
- Is the statement "Religion is high ethics. A person with high ethics is good at any age.” a hadith? Will you explain it?
- I read a hadith: "The best of you at the end of time is the one who does not have any children." I wonder if this hadith is sound or not.
- Could you explain the hadith about who is bankrupt in the hereafter? What is meant by this hadith?: “Verily, the real bankrupt of my ummah (nation) are those who come on the Day of Resurrection with prayers..."