What is the decree for a Muslim working in a church? Can a Muslim worker repair the church of a bell?
Dear Brother / Sister,
It is not makruh to work in the repairs of a church because this work is not a sin. (Bazzaziyya)
It is permissible for a Muslim to carry the wine of non-Muslims, to repair churches in return for money and to sell Christians zunnar (a kind of belt worn by non-Muslims) and similar things used only by unbelievers according to Abu Hanifa but it is not permissible according to the other mujtahids. (Raddul-Muhtar 5/251; Qadihan, NI/426; Hindiyya, IV/450 (from Muhit); Jaziri, NI/125)
However, the permissibility of working there does not show that it is a good thing. Therefore, the following is stated:
"If a Muslim makes a deal in return for five dirhams to ring the bells of a church every day with a Christian and if he finds a job in which he will earn one dirham a day, it is not appropriate for him to ring the bells of the church according to Ibrahim b. Yusuf; he should seek his sustenance doing the other job." (Qadihan, NI/404, 426)
Therefore, we advise such a person to work in another job though it is not appropriate to criticize the people who work based that fatwa.
Questions on Islam
- Is it permissible for a contractor who lives in a non-Muslim country to participate in a tender for building a church or a synagogue and for cleaning them?
- Abdullah bin Zayd (r.a.)
- Some employees get doctors certificates for being ill while they are fine and get busy with their private works. Is it possible to say that they deserve the payment of the day they do not work?
- Is it permissible to give money to beggars? If they are not in need, do the alms we give have rewards?
- Are health workers who die of an epidemic like Coronavirus regarded as martyrs?
- Is it appropriate to pay commission to someone who works in a company that we desire to sell our products to, in order to persuade them to buy your products?
- Is it permissible to work in banks and insurance companies?
- How can the transformation of St. Sophia (a church) into a mosque be explained by freedom of religion and conscience?
- Can a Muslim pray to Allah in a church?
- What are the drawbacks to worshipping in a church for a Muslim in Noel celebrations?

