Does prostration of recitation become wajib when the verse of prostration is read with the eyes, not with the tongue
Dear Brother / Sister,
Prostration of recitation (sajdah at-tilawah) becoming wajib:
If the lips are not moved and the letters are not pronounced healthily when a verse of prostration is read, prostration of recitation does not become wajib. In that case, silent reading of a verse of prostration is not enough for prostration of recitation. (Fatawa Qadihan)
It is not enough for prostration of recitation to read the first letter of the word and to omit the last letter. It is necessary to pronounce the word fully.
An example regarding the issue:
If wasju is read instead of wasjud, prostration of forgetfulness (sajdah as-sahw) becomes necessary because the letter at the end of the word has not been pronounced and the meaning has not been understood. (at-Tabyin / Zaylai)
(see Celal Yıldırım, Kaynaklarıyla İslam Fıkhı, Uysal Kitabevi: 1/437)
Questions on Islam
- If I think too much about what I am going to do in prayer, is it necessary to perform prostration of forgetfulness?
- How is the prostration of Quran recitation (sajdah at-tilawah) performed when a verse of prostration (sajdah) is read? Is it permissible to delay this prostration?
- Is it permissible to perform all prostration of recitations together after finishing reading the whole Quran?
- What should a person who does not sit after the third rak'ah of the evening prayer and stands up for the fourth rak'ah do?
- How do I rectify this mistake in a prayer?
- When is sajdah at-tilawah (prostration of recitation) made when a sajdah verse is read (recited) in the Quran?
- Sajdah as-Sahw
- Is prayer invalidated if somebody skips a verse in qira’ah or if he pronounces a different letter instead of a letter ("sin" instead of "tha")?
- How Many Kinds of Wudu are There?
- Is it necessary to perform sajdah at-tilawah when a person reads the translation of the verses of sajdah?
