Is there a hadith like this?; “No one will enter Paradise based solely on his deeds”.
Submitted by on Fri, 17/09/2010 - 11:50
Dear Brother / Sister,
The occasional presentation of Paradise as an achievement for people’s efforts work in the Qur’an is a compliment for honoring man. Otherwise, even all of worship man perform cannot be a precise thankfulness for the benefactions that were given to man by Allah beforehand.
The truth is that we are far beyond from performing the praise of benefactions such as His creation of man from nothing, equipping man with thousands of devices both physically and spiritually, granting belief, offering him/her the light, air, water and food which are needed for him/her at any time and exhibiting the earth as a dinner table for him/her where there are numerous kinds of food presented. If the whole world is given to us, we cannot sacrifice one of our eyes and likewise… That is why, it is not true to consider the worshipping as the price of benefactions that will be given in the hereafter.
Our Prophet (PBUH) points out this truth as follows:
The Prophet (pbuh) said: "No one of you will enter Paradise by his deeds alone." They asked, "Not even you, O Messenger of Allah?" He said, "Not even me, unless Allah covers me with His Grace and Mercy" (Bukhari, Riqaq, 18; Muslim, Munafiq, 71-73).
As paradise is the reward of Allah’s mercy and favor, Hell is the punishment of man’s deeds. As a matter of fact, the following is stated in the Qur’an: “Whatever good, (O man!) happens to thee is from Allah; but whatever evil happens to thee is from thyself”. (result of your sins). (See an-Nisa, 4/79)
Almighty Allah has granted numerous benefactions and favors. As man is unable to offer his thankfulness to Allah for these numerous benefactions and blessings because of his impotency, it is impossible for him/her to deserve any other benefaction. That is to say, as he/she is incapable of offering thankfulness at present, it is never ever true for him/her to say “Paradise is the reward of my deeds”, once he/she will have gained great benefactions in the hereafter like Paradise.
Man has acquired infinite benefactions that is related one another although he/she has not deserved.
For example, Almighty Allah has taken him/her into existence without leaving him/her in non-existence. This one is the biggest benefactions among other benefactions. Besides, He has given him/her the benefaction of life, by not leaving him/her in existence among lifeless things. He has given him/her the benefaction of soul by not leaving him/her soulless. He has given him/her the benefaction of reason and consciousness by not leaving him/her among things that have soul but not reason and conscious. He has bestowed him/her the benefaction of humanness among things that have reason and consciousness. He has also given him/her the benefaction of the right way and belief among humanness.
All benefactions mentioned here were delivered previously. All of them require praise and worship. Among the infinite benefactions that were offered, for how many of them did man offer thanks so that he/she could claim Paradise and say, “It is the reward of my deeds”. That is why no man including prophets can consider Paradise as a reward for his/her deeds after having entered there. Paradise is not the reward of any man’s great effort. It is only a gift and goodness of Allah’s kindness and grace.
Another issue is that man’s share in his/her worshipping and servitude is one in a hundred. That is to say, if a hundred percent of shares exist in worshipping, then ninety-nine of it belongs to Allah and one in a hundred belongs to man. Therefore, the success that is seen in man’s deed belongs to Allah. The share and wealth that belongs to man is his/her weak and doubtful demand and willing. Man wills, and Allah creates it. Then the dominant side in man’s deed is Allah. So how can a man deserve Paradise solely through his/her deeds?
However, Hell is justice. The sins and evils that take man to hell are not bodily beings like good deeds and thawabs (rewards). Evils and sins are things that take place due to absence of will and duty, that are like destruction and that do not belong to the class of beings
For instance, the construction of a building by a hundred workers in a hundred days is an example of good deeds and bodily being. Demolishing that building using a match and dynamites is an example of evil and sin. To construct a building is like good deeds and thawabs. To demolish a building is like evils and sins. The share of man in good deeds is short and narrow but it is long and wide in evils and sins
Therefore, man is active in destruction and evils; he is passive in thawabs and good deeds. Therefore, although it is just to record a thousand sins for an evil deed, Allah records only one sin due to His mercy and grace; although it is extra to record even one thawab for a good deed, He records one thousand thawabs due to his benevolence and generosity
We deserve Hell due to our sins and mistakes but we do not deserve Paradise due to our good deeds; Paradise is a grace and bounty of Allah.
Questions on Islam
- Does Freedom mean doing whatever someone happens to want? If not, how should real freedom be understood?
- Are all of our sins forgiven during Ramadan?
- What does it mean to love and to hate for the sake of Allah? What should one understand from it? How should one love and hate for the sake of Allah?
- Learning of which sciences gain us the reward (thawab) of worshipping?
- What is fasting? What is the Religious Decree of Fasting?
- I am afraid of having children in this age. Is it appropriate not to think of having children due to the things happening at the end of time?
- If our prayer does not prevent us from shameful and unjust deeds, does it mean that the prayers we perform will not be accepted?
- Is it permissible to despise sinners or non-Muslims and humiliate them?
- Can I have a chance to select or change the person whom I am going to marry by praying?
- Does a person go directly to Paradise if his thawabs outweigh his sins when deeds are weighed in the Gathering Place?