Does the belief of a person leave if he commits fornication? The following is stated in a hadith: "A person is not a believer while he is committing fornication."
Submitted by on Fri, 13/10/2017 - 16:04
Dear Brother / Sister,
Hz. Abu Hurayra narrates: The Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said,
"When a person commits fornication, belief departs from him and there is something like a canvas roof over his head; and when he quits that action, belief returns to him." [Abu Dawud, Sunnah 16, (4690); Tirmidhi, Iman 11, (2627).]
Tirmidhi has the following extra information:
"Abu Jafer al-Baqir Muhammed Ibn Ali said, He said, ‘like this’" and he interlocked his fingers; then, he separated his fingers and said, ‘When he repents, it returns.’ Then, he interlocked his fingers again."
In Hakim, an explanation from Abu Hurayra is included. The explanation is as follows:
"If a person commits fornication or drinks alcohol, Allah removes belief from him, just like a person taking off his sweater from his head."
The extra information in Tirmidhi brought about the following interpretation:
"Abu Ja'far separated belief from Islam and gave belief a special identity. Thus, a person remains in Islam even if he exits from belief. Ibn Hajar states that this interpretation is compatible with the statement of the majority of fiqh scholars: "What is meant by the belief in the hadith is perfect belief, not belief itself."
(Prof. Dr. İbrahim Canan, Kütüb-i Sitte)
Questions on Islam
- Will you write the hadith about the Prophet’s (pbuh) advice to the young person who wanted to commit fornication?
- Abu Ubayda bin Jarrah (r.a.)
- Abu Hurayra (r.a.)
- Is it true that a person who commits the sin of associating partners with Allah will not be forgiven?
- The Prophet (pbuh) said, "If there were a prophet after me, it would be Umar." He said the following about Hz. Abu Bakr; " If the belief of all people were put on one scale of a balance and Abu Bakr's belief on the other, his belief would outweigh."
- How should the phrase "Allah wondered and laughed" mentioned in the hadith be understood?
- "By Allah! If you knew what I know, you would laugh little and you would cry much; you would not taste the pleasures of your women in the beds, and you would go out beseeching Allah." Will you explain this hadith?
- Will you give information about mutashabih hadiths? (He will open His leg and show His thigh; artists; in a cloud...)
- There is a hadith that is narrated as follows: "An illegitimate child is the evilest of the three evils." How should this narration be interpreted under the light of the verse, "No bearer of burdens can bear the burden of another"?
- How do we understand that we believe in Allah's existence by approving it with our heart? How do we understand whether we believe in something or not?