Was it Prophet Muhammad’s Will to Make Hazrat Abu Bakr the First Caliph of Islam?

The Details of the Question
Was it Prophet Muhammad’s Will to Make Hazrat Abu Bakr the First Caliph of Islam?
The Answer

Dear Brother / Sister,

The Prophet did not directly appoint Hazrat Abu Bakr to caliphate. However, we can deduce from some of his words and practices that he wanted Hazrat Abu Bakr to be the first caliph.

The Status of Four Caliphs amongst Other Companions

It is stated that the most decent of all ummah are the companions and that Hazrat Abu Bakr deserved the title of “siddiq” (trustworthy, loyal) because of affirming Hazrat Muhammad’s prophethood and Miraj without any hesitation. (1) Although this explanation is short and not clear, we deduce a reason why Abu Bakr was the most decent of all companions from it. This reason is the fact that he was very faithful and submissive. His loyalty to Allah and His Messenger was unwavering. There are some other reasons which make him the most decent of all companions in addition to these. Factors such as that he was a leader in faith, paved way to the good and he played a significant role in the belief of generations after him, he supported the Messenger of Allah both physically and financially in the most risky times, his understanding of Islam and his worshipping elevate him to the highest degree amongst ummah and companions.

At-Taftazani stated that Hazrat Omar was given the title of “Faruq” (discerning truth from falsehood) because he distinguished truth from falsehood in his judgments and causes. (2) This points out to that he deemed truth, Islam which is the truth more important than anything and that he submitted himself to the truth. When he converted into Islam, he challenged fearlessly Kuraish and the whole world in the name of theirs (3). It is understood that how he sided with the truth and how strongly he believed in truth. This indicates that this was one of his superiorities. (4)

Then he stated that Hazrat Othman firstly married Ruqiyya, a daughter of the Messenger of Allah, and when she died, he married his other daughter Ummu Gulsum and thus he was named “Zinnurayn” (having two lights), and that the Prophet said “If I had one more daughter, I would marry her to you again”. (5) We deduce from this that the Prophet was very pleased with Hazrat Othman; he loved him a lot, and appreciated him. Of course, he would not love anyone because of his personal interests. Hazrat Muhammad’s dearest friends were true believes and people with taqwa. If he loved Hazrat Othman, appreciated him and stated that he was pleased with him, we need to follow the Messenger of Allah and appreciate Hazrat Othman, love him and have high opinions of him, and we should not criticize him. If the Prophet loved him that much and married his daughters to him, this shows that he was a true believer and he had taqwa; because Muslims do not marry their daughters to unbelievers. This means he was a believer. He was a muttaqi (one with taqwa; God-conscious) as the Messenger of Allah put it. And angels respected him (6).

At-Taftazani then stated that Hazrat Ali al-Murtaza was one of good servants to Allah and proved his sincerity. (7) Nasafi and other ahl-i sunnah interpreters of Quran named Hazrat Ali as Murtaza in order to stress that Allah and His Messenger were pleased with him (8). Allah and His Messenger love Hazrat Ali a lot. He loves them both a lot, too and pleased them. This was mentioned in hadiths, too (9). Taftazani states that Hazrat Ali was outstanding in his worship, sincerity and asceticism. One who is loved by Allah and His Messenger, one with whom they were pleased, and one who was son-in-law of the Messenger of Allah was of course a true believer, God-conscious and worthy of praise and love. Moreover, Allah the Glorious stated that he was friend to the Messenger of Allah (10).

According to at-Taftazani, the companions put four caliphs in superiority order according to their caliphate order. At-Taftazani says “It is clear that they would not have decided this if they had not had proofs.” (11)

2) Some hadiths point out to caliphs’ order of virtuousness:

If hadiths are examined for the purpose of this issue, it will be seen that they have got signs pointing out to the degrees and order of caliphate of four caliphs:

Hazrat Ali, the father of Muhammad bin Hanafiyya, was asked: “Who is the most virtuous person after the Messenger of Allah?” Hazrat Ali answered clearly by listing in order “Abu Bakr, Omar and Othman.” (12) The hadith related to the ones given the tidings of deserving Heaven states that the first to arrive at Eris Well was Abu Bakr, then Omar and then Othman. (13) This may be an indication of their order of virtuousness. Moreover, one day the Messenger of Allah, Abu Bakr, Omar and Othman climbed up Uhud Mountain. Then when the mountains started to tremble, the Messenger called to the mountain: “Stop O Uhud! There are the Prophet, Siddiq and two martyrs on you!” (14)

Bukhari mentioned the names of companions in the hadith above in this order: “Abu Bakr, Omar, and Othman.” Also, the Messenger of Allah mentioned Abu Bakr after himself in the hadith above, and after Abu Bakr, mentioned Omar and Othman. Is it not a sing of Abu Bakr’s superiority that the Prophet mentioned him right after himself? Moreover, this hadith harbingered that Hazrat Omar and Hazrat Othman were going to be martyred.

In another hadith narrated from Hazrat Ali, the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) said: “I became one with Abu Bakr and Omar. I worked with Abu Bakr and Omar. I walked with Abu Bakr and Omar…” (15) This indicates that Abu Bakr ranks in first place in terms of superiority and then comes Omar amongst other companions and the ummah.

Again in another hadith from Bukhari’s book, Abdullah bin Omar narrated: “He said: ‘We would not deem anyone equal to Abu Bakr, and then to Omar and then to Othman in the time of the Prophet (pbuh). After that, we quit comparing the companions of The Messenger of Allah according to their superiority.” (16),

When this hadith is taken into consideration, there are several aspects one comes up with:

First: Abdullah bin Abbas (death H. 68), as a knowledgeable and wise companion, speaks of a matter which was agreed upon and known by everyone in the time of the Messenger of Allah (pbuh). It is that none of the companions were deemed equal in virtuousness to the four caliphs, especially to Hazrat Abu Bakr. (17) Of course, the Messenger of Allah knew that his companions thought like that. He thought the same, too. If he had not thought like this, he would have corrected their opinions.

Second: Abdullah bin Abbas, while narrating the hadith, firstly mentions Hazrat Abu Bakr, and then caliphs in order. It can be deduced from this that Hazrat Abu Bakr was the leading one in virtuousness and also that Abdullah bin Abbas agreed with it.

Third: According to this hadith, the four caliphs are superior to all companions. And the degree of superiority between them is based on this order.

Fourth: Companions deemed the companions in question superior to others according to the given order; however, they did not ever compare other companions in superiority. This problem of superiority emerged later. (18)

The order of their caliphate, their works and services during their caliphates and events that occurred during their caliphates can also be considered to be signs of their virtuousness.

After discussing this problem, at-Taftazani says: “Salaf (companions and tabiin) agreed on Othman’s superiority over Ali and accepts their order of caliphate as it is. (19) Then he explains how each of them was promoted to caliphate one by one. In his opinion, the caliphate of the four caliphs was the result of consensus of Islamic scholars. Conflicts and wars which happened related to the caliphate of Hazrat Ali were not because of disagreement over his caliphate indeed, but because of the fault in deduction (of judgment; ijtihad).” (20)

As it is seen, Taftazani considers wars during the time of Hazrat Ali as the result of deduction and faults in deduction, like other ahl-i Sunnah scholars. It is not meant to criticize and oppose to the companion here; conversely, it is meant to exalt him. Taftazani blames them with hypocrisy and heedlessness. He states that Hazrat Ali was right on his judgment and Muawiya was faulty in his judgment. Muawiya, who was faulty in his judgment, is not criticized or blamed with straying and hypocrisy but commemorated nicely as a mujtahid, because mujtahids will earn sawabs even though they are faulty in their judgments. A mujtahid who made a mistake in his judgment cannot be blamed with straying or hypocrisy. (21)

Bediuzzaman Said Nursi says that some Quranic verses point out to the four caliphs to come after the death of the Messenger of Allah, together with their order, and hints who they are by telling their most known features:

“Muhammad is the Prophet of God, and those who are with him are strong against unbelievers, [but] compassionate among each other. You will see them bow and prostrate themselves....” (surah-al-Fath)
Through telling of the elevated qualities and characteristics which were the reason for the
Companions being the most elevated of human kind after the prophets, the start of this verse describes through its explicit meaning the excellent qualities which would mark the class of the Companions. And through its implied meaning, the verse alludes to the Rightly-Guided Caliphs, who would succeed to the office of the Prophet (PBUH) after his death through the institution of the Caliphate, and gives news of the fine attributes which were what most distinguished each of them and marked them out. It is as follows:

“And those who are with him” alludes to Abu Bakr al-Siddiq, who was distinguished and famous for being among the Prophet’s special followers and party to his conversation, and again for entering among his special followers by being the first to die.

“While are strong against the unbelievers” points to Umar, who in the future would cause the countries of the globe to tremble at his conquests, and with his justice would descend on tyrants like a thunderbolt.

“And compassionate among each other” gives news of Uthman, who, in the future when the most serious dissension was being fomented, would sacrifice his own life and spirit out of perfect kindness and compassion so that the blood of Muslims should not be spilt, preferring to be martyred wrongfully while reading the Qur’an.

And so too, “You will see them bow and prostrate themselves [in prayer], seeking grace from God and [His] good pleasure” tells that with his complete worthiness to undertake the Caliphate and government, and his heroism, and his choosing perfect asceticism, worship, poverty, and frugality, and whose bowing and prostrating in prayer was corroborated by everyone, Ali (May God be pleased with him) was not responsible for his position in the future and the wars and strife in which he was involved, and that his intention and wish was for Divine favour.

The phrase, “This is their similitude in the Torah” makes predictions concerning the Unseen in two respects: It gives news of the qualities of the Companions mentioned in the Torah, which was as though the Unseen for an unlettered person like the Prophet (Upon whom be blessings and peace).

The sentence, “and their similitude in the Gospel is: like a seed which sends forth its blade, then makes it strong; it then becomes thick, and it stands on its own stem, [filling] the sowers with wonder and delight. As a result, it fills the unbelievers with rage at them”, gives news of the Unseen in two respects:
The First is the prediction concerning the Companions in the Gospel, which was like the Unseen for the unlettered Prophet (PBUH).

At the start the Companions would appear to be few and weak, nevertheless they would burgeon like seeds, grow, thicken, and find strength. When they were about to be overwhelmed and smothered by the rage that this would cause the unbelievers, they would subjugate mankind with their swords and prove that the Prophet (PBUH), their leader, was the Ruler of the World. The verses express exactly the meaning of the above verses of Sura al-Fath.

Second Aspect: These sentences predict the following: the Companions certainly accepted the Pact of Hudaybiya out of their weakness and small number, but within a short time they so grew and acquired such strength and loftiness that, planted by the Hand of Power in the field of the face of the earth, they multiplied in most elevated, powerful, fruitful, and plentiful fashion. Especially in relation to the shoots of mankind at that time, which were short, weak, defective, and scant due to neglect and heedlessness. They would grow strong and cause glorious states to rage at them in envy, jealousy, and anger. Yes, the future verified this prediction in most brilliant fashion.

There is in this prediction the further following slight hint: it indicates through the word forgiveness that, although while praising the Companions’ excellent qualities they should have been promised the greatest rewards, in the future serious faults would arise among the Companions, due to strife. For forgiveness indicates the existence of faults. And at that time the thing most demanded by the Companions, the greatest bounty, would be forgiveness. (22)

The Hint about the Four Caliphs

In addition to this last verse of surah al-Fath which hints the caliphs to come after the Messenger of Allah, the verse “All who obey God and the Messenger are in the company of those on whom is the Grace of God, - of the prophets (who teach), the sincere (lovers of Truth), the witnesses (who testify), and the Righteous (who do good): Ah! What a beautiful fellowship!” (al-Nisa, 69) also indicates the same truth.

This verse describes the people of the Straight Path and the groups of the Prophets, the caravan of the Veracious, the community of the Martyrs, the class of the Righteous, and those who follow them, who are those among mankind who truly receive the Divine bounties, and furthermore, explicitly pointing out the most perfect of those five groups in the World of Islam, it then indicates the leaders and chiefs of those five groups through mentioning their well-known attributes. In addition, with a flash of miraculousness giving news of the Unseen, it specifies in one respect those chiefs’ positions in the future.

Yes, of the Prophets looks explicitly to the Prophet Muhammad (Upon whom be blessings and peace), and the phrase the Veracious looks to Abu Bakr al-Siddiq (the Veracious). It also indicates that he would be second after the Prophet (Upon whom be blessings and peace), and first to succeed to his place, and be known with the special title of ‘Siddiq,’ and be seen at the head of all the veracious.

Then the Witnesses [or Martyrs] mentions Umar, Uthman, and Ali (May God be pleased with all of them) together. It indicates indirectly that the three of them would succeed to the Caliphate of the Prophet after ‘al-Siddiq,’ that the three of them would be martyred, and the merits of martyrdom added to their other virtues.

The Righteous alludes to distinguished persons like the Companions of the Bench, and of Badr and Ridwan.

While the explicit meaning of “And how goodly a company are these!” encourages others to follow them, and its implicit meaning, through showing the generation that succeeded them to be honoured and illustrious, alludes to Hasan (May God be pleased with him), who as the fifth Caliph affirmed the Hadith “After me the Caliphate will last thirty years” (23) -in order to show its great value despite its brief duration. (24)

And the word “goodly” in the Quranic verse which is translated as “And how goodly a company are these!” is “hasune” in Arabic text. And in Arabic writing, Hassan and Hasune are written in the same way.

As it is seen, there are many sings and hints pointing out to the Unseen, stated either explicitly or implicitly in Quranic verses. They also hint in which order the four caliphs will be promoted to the caliphate.


(1) Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli p. 177-178.
(2) ibid., p. 178.
(3) History of Islam, p. 172 ff.
(4) The Messenger of Allah declares Hazrat Omar’s piety by means of a dream. Sahihu'l-Bukhari, IV, 201.
(5) Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli p. 178.
(6) For hadiths about him, see Sahîhu'l-Buhârî IV, 196 (those who were given the news of deserving Heaven), IV, 202 ff.
(7) Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli p. 178.
(8) Sherhu'l-Akaid p. 322.
(9) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 207 (This is explained in the hadith related to the war of Haybar) Moreover, while on war expedition of Tebuk, the Messenger of Allah (pbuh) stated that his position with him was like that of Moses’ with Aaron.
(10) See. Al-Maidah 5/55; at-Taberi, Muhibbuddîn Ahmad b. Abdullah Zehairu'l-Ukba,
Cairo, 1357, p. 102 ff.
(11 Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli Ala Sherhi'l-Akaid p. 178.
(12) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 195 (Fezai'l-Bab, 5).
(13) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 196.
(14) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 197; 204.
(15) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 197.
(16) Sahîhu'l-Bukhârî IV, 203.
(17) For the word “adala”see al-Mu'jemu'l-Wasît p. 588; al-Mufredat p. 325.
(18) For the issue of that Companions are more virtuous than all ummah and that four caliphs are more virtuous than the others, see  al-Haytami, Ahmad b. Hajar, as-Sawaiku'l-Muhrika, s.
210, 213; Subulu's-Selam IV, 127 (witnesses/martyrs); Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli p.
(19) Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli , alâ Sherhi'l-Akâid s. 179.
(20) Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli 'ala Sherhu'l-Akâid s. 180.
(21) Bk. Şerhu'l-Akâid s. 325, Hashiyatu'l-Kestelli 'alâ Şerhi'l-Akâid, s. 180-181.

(22)See. Nursi, The Flashes, p. 29-32.
(23) Tirmidhi, Fiten, 48.
(24)See. Nursi, The Flashes, p. 33-34.

Prof. Dr. Murat Sarıcık

Questions on Islam

Was this answer helpful?
Questions on Islam
Subject Categories:
Read 7.282 times
In order to make a comment, please login or register